

When the film was re-released with its toned-down terror, it eventually became a hit and cemented Lon Chaney’s claim to stardom. Why? Universal was dismayed to discover that audiences found it scary and suspenseful. In fact, The Phantom was pulled back for tinkering after its premiere. The movie horror genre was still very young and no one was sure how far they could go. The film is often classified as horror but that’s not truly accurate. At yet, these pluses continue to overwhelm the minuses of this unique production. Lon Chaney’s performance has to make up for the dreadful acting of his co-stars. Gorgeous sets and costumes are undermined by lackluster direction. However, even its most devoted fans admit that the film is deeply flawed. The Phantom of the Opera remains a beloved classic of silent cinema.

Therefore, I shall be spoiling the living daylights out of it. Also, as this is one of the most viewed silent movies of all time, I am taking for granted that everyone has at least a passing familiarity with it.

Notes: This is my 150 th silent film review and so I am pulling out all the stops. Who would want to see Lon Chaney play a monster? Home Media Availability: Released on DVD, Blu-ray and via streaming.
